Your web browser is out of date. Update your browser for more security, speed and the best experience on this site.

Update your browser
Fortepan / Gabor Viktor

The Disorder of My Same-Sex Attraction

Order: Issue Three

Amy E. Hamilton

Pink, orange, brown, and white stripes ran like rivulets down my uniform. Even for the early 80’s, the fashion was questionable, but the messaging was clear: the shirt displayed a reconfigured rainbow of classic Neapolitan flavors with a stripe of orange added in, alluding to orange sherbert and other flavors available outside the traditional trio. Baskin Robbins was my first real job and the place to go for good ice cream and options: 31 of them. Peanut butter and chocolate was my number one favorite, my dad alternated between pralines and cream or butter pecan, and my mom loved chocolate almond. While our subjective tastes varied, eating any of these flavors in moderation fulfilled the telos of the human appetite for something cold and sweet. 

By 1985, the ice cream menu wasn’t the only thing being expanded. A “Baskin Robbins” view of sexuality was emerging too, pushing against religious and societal bounds, and more voices were heard saying: whatever your sexual preference, whatever your “flavor,” was okay. Divorce had hit its all-time peak and was just slightly easing off. If your marital taste had changed, so we were encouraged to think, try a different selection. For many, marriage was no longer a permanent vocation. In my high school and church youth group, discerning a vocation meant choosing a college, a major, and a career. I did not hear marriage discussed. And the reimagined rainbow of gay Pride—the ultimate panoply of flavors—was becoming a publicly recognized symbol. 

Though most Christian churches were still clear on the immorality of same-sex sexual behavior, the Sexual Revolution advanced through my generation, and I was absorbing a distorted message. The telos of sex was pleasure, so whichever form of sexual engagement one found most pleasurable, that was the one to pursue.  I was fifteen and had secretly been struggling with same-sex attraction for three years. Later that year, I wore a tuxedo to the high school Christmas dance, unwittingly leading the entire school to suspect my secret. 

In college, I came out, openly identified as lesbian, and had same-sex relationships. I had become a Christian in high school, but I decided that I could not fight my attractions any longer. At first, I felt happy and “free.” The only problem was that my conscience was deeply troubled; I was being convicted of sin, no matter how much I tried to suppress the truth. Though I had never heard the term “Natural Law,” even my body seemed to bear witness to an order I was going against, desire and pleasure notwithstanding. I knew I must repent and return to walking with God, the One who designed my body in the first place. 

My attractions, however, remained. I did not want to leave my lesbian identity and life. Yet I knew Jesus was calling me to forsake sin and take up my cross. My choice was clear: old self or new? Follow Him or follow my own ways? So, I surrendered my sexuality to God and focused on following Him. I honestly never thought my same-sex attraction (SSA) would even lessen in degree, and I fully expected to be single, celibate, and perhaps struggling, for the rest of my life. But, like Peter, I had nowhere else to turn: “Lord, to whom else shall we go? You have the words of everlasting life.” 

Same-sex sexual relationships are neither unitive nor complementary and can never be fruitful. I had a sexual appetite for things that could not fulfill God’s design or telos for my female body.

Upon my surrender, my battle with temptation felt constant. My desire to return to a same-sex relationship was stronger than anything I had ever felt. I was holding on with white knuckles, trying to walk a different path, but wondering all the while whether I could make it. In desperation, I cried out to God. I began meditating on Jesus and His temptation in the desert. I contemplated how, after forty days, Jesus had legitimate hunger. But He did not wrongly use His power to meet His needs. He refused to turn stones into bread. And it was only after He resisted Satan’s offers that the ministry of the angels came. I called this to mind often as I struggled to wait on God.

My repentance was still fresh when a card from my ex-girlfriend arrived in the mail—the biggest temptation yet. I called a friend. “Of course she would come back into my life now. I’m being kicked while I’m down…here I am trying to follow Christ, and this is the one woman I can’t resist.” I finished my self-pitying rant by declaring, “But I’m not going to do it. I will not turn these stones into bread.”

And as I spoke those words, I closed the card. I had been so quick to open to its message, I hadn’t paid attention to the cover. There on the front was a single image—a pile of stones. The photo title on the back read: “Stones on a beach.” In that moment, I knew what God was saying to me. “I know you are hungry. This is not bread.” My hunger was legitimate; satisfying it through a same-sex relationship was not. I was going to have to wait on God and trust Him to give me bread in His time. In Jesus’ own words: “What father among you, if his child asks for bread, would give him a stone?”

“Thirty-one flavors” sexuality is false—there are not numerous equivalent options to choose from. The choice is between bread (in keeping with God’s design and law) and stones. Stones are neither nutritive nor designed for digestion. Same-sex sexual relationships are neither unitive nor complementary and can never be fruitful. I had a sexual appetite for things that could not fulfill God’s design or telos for my female body. And just as I was not designed to eat stones, I was not designed for same-sex relations. God did not create me to be “gay.” Despite the tenacity of my same-sex attraction, I was not a third category of human, nor were my body and reproductive system differently ordered. In my sexuality, my Father did not say that stones would serve as bread for me. He wouldn’t bend the Natural Law for me, but He would help me live in harmony with it. God asked me to trust Him because He is good, and only within His will can I flourish and be free. 

How difficult was this to live out? In a story too long to tell, I took a five-year detour through an emotionally enmeshed relationship with an older woman, “Liz,” a counselor who seduced me when I went to the Bible Church for help. We managed to stop the overt sexual activity after six months, but then she was my world for the next four and a half. I know there was exploitation. I also know I experienced this as my “best life”: a celibate same-sex partnership. I told her I would take care of her when she was old. Sadly, this distorted and all-consuming relationship shaped the rest of my young development until I was 25.  

When I finally left that relationship—another act of obedience done with reluctance and tears—God led me to a faithful evangelical Church that discipled me and taught me to renew my mind with Scripture. When Jesus refused to turn the stones into bread, He said we would live, not by bread alone, but by the words of God. For years, as I tried to “put off the old self” and “put on the new,” I had been forgetting the step of “being renewed in the spirit of my mind.” Now I was feeding on the words of God, intentionally asking the Holy Spirit to reveal any lies I had believed or attitudes that were not of God. I repented of them and began filling my mind with His truth.

This discipline in repentance proved astonishingly effective in transforming stubborn areas of my thinking that I had felt powerless to change. With respect to SSA, I confronted the aversion I had to opposite-sex relations, which was complicated by the fact that I had found same-sex relations so pleasurable. I knew my thinking was in error, and I did not want to find God’s ordering of human sexuality repellent, so I gathered verses contrasting the pleasures of the flesh with the pleasures of God, His intentions for marriage, and the mystery of the one-flesh union. When I struggled to keep my thoughts pure and combatted memories of my past, Psalm 145:7 became a beacon: “They shall eagerly utter the memory of Your abundant goodness and will shout joyfully of Your righteousness.” Practicing this spiritual discipline reframed the pleasurable memories of sin in light of truth and their power faded. As I chose to praise the God whose “love is better than life,” my sense of pleasure and what I delighted in began to change as well.

For years, I was nurtured in this faithful church community. I matured in my faith, grew in contentment, and pursued the union I was made for—union with Christ. For over a decade, I stayed single and celibate. Those years were honestly painful and yet truly full of joy. I was surprised as my SSA lessened and my struggles became less frequent. Wondrously, I no longer wished that same-sex relationships were morally acceptable. I had come to trust the Creator and His goodness and wisdom. I had come to delight in the law of the Lord, not wish that I could change it. As I turned 30, I even saw a flicker of heterosexual desire emerge, but I was sure I would remain single. 

To my utter surprise, I married at age 37. What if I had tarried in disordered friendships? What if I had resisted obedience?  The opportunity for my marriage would certainly have disappeared. What if I had been in a church that blessed same-sex couples, or even one that compromised with blessing “celibate unions”? What would I have missed? I shudder, as I picture the two faces most precious to me, daughters born of my body at age 38 and 41, never coming into being.

My younger self had desperately wanted homosexual relationships to be morally acceptable. The unchosen experience of SSA coupled with the Judeo-Christian prohibition seemed an irresolvable tension, and I questioned the goodness of God and the wisdom of His moral law. Through these years I witnessed various Christians wrestling with the Biblical text, as if the profound anthropological issue at stake could come down to a few verses, and that if we just got rid of them, that would make it all okay. But any hermeneutic that sets aside the objective witness of the body is an anti-incarnational deception.

Just as the imago Dei is etched into each of our cells as either male or female, this pattern of complementarity is infused throughout His Creation. To reject the one-flesh union established in Genesis is to reject the truth about ourselves, the dust of the garden from which we were fashioned, and the ground on which we stand. We can’t erase a few verses or check a box to make same-sex pairings equal to marital ones. We would have to build another world. And in so doing, we would be saying to our Creator who called His creation and pairing of male and female “very good”: we know better than you. 

Once in graduate school, I saw what I thought was my favorite comic strip posted outside a professor’s office and went over to look. The strip was entitled “Schulz is Dead.” The frames had no dialogue, just sketches of beloved characters in sexual poses with each other, in groups, in every variation and combination possible. How I wish I hadn’t looked. Today, much of our society clearly tries to draw the same strip (Nietzsche’s “God is Dead”). Through technology and changing mores, we have built some of our “better” world. We see glimpses of it regularly on social media, a continuous series of frames, where helpless babies vainly root at men’s chests rather than their mothers’ breasts; where evidence of a global demographic winter is undeniable; where destroying the babies we do produce is a badge of honor.  This tragic, not comic, strip reveals that when the order of creation is rejected, we suffer. Disorder is painful and it leaves us restless and unfulfilled, alienated in body and mind. Human sexuality bears an intrinsic logic and dynamism rooted in the male and female forms. The exquisite complementarity of our bodies is a basic—and beautiful—fact. It’s not an option or a preference or a taste.  Happily, ice cream comes in great varieties; healthy human sexuality doesn’t.  

What man among you, if his son asks for bread, would give him a stone?

A good father will not give his children stones. And I know from experience: My Father gives me bread. 

Amy E. Hamilton, Ph.D., is an adjunct professor at the Nesti Center for Faith & Culture at the University of St. Thomas, Houston. Her work can be found at amyhamilton.org. Portions of this essay have appeared on the “What We Need Now” Substack and in Lived Experience and the Search for Truth. Revisiting Catholic Sexual Morality (En Route Books, 2024). Reprinted here with permission.

Posted on November 20, 2026

Recommended Reading

Affective Maturity and Priestly Celibacy: When Love Is Rightly Ordered (Part Two)

Paul Check

“And when you have turned again, strengthen your brethren,” Jesus tells Peter (Lk 22:32), which can be interpreted to mean both fortify them as individual disciples (and priests) and in their common bond of love for each other in Christ. Having recognized the safeguard against self-promotion, then we consider how men, within a healthy brotherhood, can encourage and bolster each other in virtue, by their example and fraternal solicitude for each other. At the Last Supper, Jesus told His first priests, “By this all men will know that you are my disciples, if you have love for one another” (Jn 13:35). 

Read Full Article
Fortepan / Hámori Gyula

Affective Maturity and Priestly Celibacy: When Love Is Rightly Ordered (Part One)

Paul Check

Now seems the acceptable time for the Church to clarify further the meaning of “affective maturity” in seminary formation, given the widespread confusion over what it means to be human. Given the radical and regrettable changes in how many now understand what it means to be human and to act in a human way, this essay proposes that we need a more detailed account of the content of affective maturity, consistent with the complementarity of the sexes. 

Read Full Article

American Law and the Cosmological Deracination of the Family

David Crawford

Many will recall the New York City “drag march” during “Pride Month” celebrations a couple of years ago, which made news when participants began chanting “We’re here, we’re queer, we’re coming for your children.” Many will also recall that march organizers offered somewhat limp assurances that the chant was not to be taken seriously, that it was “taken out of context,” or that it was only intended to mock the “moral panic” ignited by the gender wars.

Read Full Article
Humanum: Issues in Family, Culture & Science
Pontifical John Paul II Institute for Studies on Marriage and Family
620 Michigan Ave. N.E. (McGivney Hall)
Washington, DC 20064